As a content creator for keyfobprog.com and an automotive repair specialist, I’ve experienced firsthand the differences between OEM and replica parts. Today, I’m diving into a comparison of Golf Mk6 Tail Lights, specifically OEM Cherry Red and Replica Golf R LED versions. Having owned and installed both on my Mk6 GTI, I’m here to share my insights to help you make an informed decision.
Initially, budget-conscious, I opted for Replica Golf R tail lights due to their attractive price point. However, upon arrival, the overly dark tint was immediately apparent, clashing with my preference for a cleaner, OEM+ aesthetic rather than a “racer boy” style. This led to listing them for sale, and during that process, questions arose about rear fog light functionality and reverse light integration, prompting an attempted installation.
Installation of the replica tail lights revealed a significant issue: poor fitment. Despite adjustments, the lights failed to align correctly with the car’s body lines. Uneven and unsightly gaps were present around the edges, raising concerns about overall quality, even considering their origin. While the material quality seemed acceptable for aftermarket parts, the fitment was undeniably problematic.
Disappointed, I sold the replica set and invested in genuine OEM Cherry Red LED tail lights sourced directly from Germany. The replicas cost around $410, while the OEM set was approximately $550. The wait for the OEM lights was about 20 days for shipping from Germany, but the moment they arrived, the difference was clear.
Installing the OEM golf mk6 tail lights was a breeze, taking only about 20 minutes. Remarkably, no adjustments were needed; they aligned perfectly with the body lines right out of the box. The gaps surrounding the lights were even and consistent on both sides, a stark contrast to the replicas.
OEM Cherry Red GTD Golf MK6 tail lights installed, showcasing perfect body line alignment.
Aesthetically, while personal preference plays a role, I find the Cherry Red LED tails more appealing than the tinted Golf R style, especially on lighter colored vehicles. The Golf R tinted versions might complement darker car colors better, but for overall clarity and a refined look, Cherry Red wins in my book.
The following images highlight the fitment discrepancies. Notice the uneven and larger gaps with the Replica LED tail lights compared to the consistent, minimal gaps achieved with the OEM golf mk6 tail lights.
Replica Golf R MK6 tail lights showing a noticeable gap at the bottom, indicating poor fitment.
Another view of the replica tail light gap, emphasizing the misalignment with the vehicle body.
Close-up of the replica tail light gap, highlighting the uneven fit and finish.
OEM Cherry Red MK6 tail lights demonstrating tight and even gaps, showcasing superior fitment.
In conclusion, while replica golf mk6 tail lights may seem like a cost-saving alternative, my experience strongly suggests that the investment in OEM quality is worthwhile. The superior fitment, ease of installation, and overall finish of the OEM Cherry Red LED tail lights justify the higher price. For enthusiasts seeking quality and perfect aesthetics for their Golf MK6, OEM tail lights are undoubtedly the recommended choice.
